Top Hidden Gems in Muskoka: Places Locals Love

If you're looking to explore Muskoka like a local, skip the usual tourist traps and check out these under-the-radar gems. From cozy eateries to scenic hiking trails, these local favourites are what make Muskoka truly magical—whether you’re just visiting or planning to stay awhile.

Belly Artisan Ice Cream (Huntsville)

Small-batch and full of personality, Belly is a sweet little secret tucked away in Huntsville. With bold, unique flavours made in-house, this ice cream shop is a must-visit after a day exploring local Muskoka nature trails or relaxing by the lake.

Erika’s Bakery (Dwight)

You haven’t truly experienced Dwight until you’ve had a butter tart from Erika’s. This homey bakery offers warm service, hearty breakfast sandwiches, and old-school treats that are a must for anyone looking to taste authentic Muskoka flavours.

3 Guys and a Stove (Huntsville)

Just off the beaten path, this beloved restaurant serves creative comfort food with global inspiration. Locals and visitors alike consider it one of the best restaurants in Muskoka for its cozy setting and unique, wood-fired dishes.

El Pueblito (Bracebridge)

A tiny but mighty gem, El Pueblito brings authentic Mexican cuisine to the heart of cottage country. It’s one of the most unexpected and flavourful things to do in Muskoka for food lovers.

Wabora Fusion Japanese (Bracebridge)

Yes, you can get amazing sushi in Muskoka. Wabora serves up a fresh, beautifully presented fusion menu with standout rolls, noodles, and more. It’s a local favourite for those craving city-quality meals in a cottage country setting.

Main St. Local Kitchen (Huntsville)

This farm-to-table spot offers elevated comfort food using locally sourced ingredients. Known as one of Huntsville’s top food spots, it’s perfect for a weekend brunch or casual dinner after a day on the trails.

Marigold Unique Flavour (Bracebridge)

Spice up your Muskoka visit with a stop at Marigold. Offering authentic Indian cuisine in a cozy setting, it’s one of the most beloved hidden restaurants in Bracebridge, and a go-to for locals who know where to eat in Muskoka.

Discover Muskoka’s Best Nature Trails and Scenic Spots

Limberlost Forest & Wildlife Reserve (Huntsville)

This expansive, privately owned reserve offers free access to over 10,000 acres of untouched wilderness. With a network of trails winding through lakes, forests, and wildlife habitats, it’s one of the top Muskoka hidden gems for hikers and outdoor lovers.

Huckleberry Rock Lookout (Muskoka Lakes)

A short hike with a big reward. This lookout features ancient exposed rock and sweeping views of Lake Muskoka. It’s a favourite among locals for sunset hikes and peaceful moments above the tree line.

Hardy Lake Provincial Park (Torrance)

Quiet and rugged, Hardy Lake’s loop trail includes a wooden footbridge to a small island and is surrounded by crystal-clear waters. It’s the perfect choice if you're seeking scenic hiking trails in Muskoka without the crowds.

Wilson’s Falls Trail (Bracebridge)

Lesser known than other Muskoka waterfalls, Wilson’s Falls offers a tranquil, winding trail along the water’s edge. It’s one of those spots that locals treasure—ideal for a morning walk, nature photography, or a quiet escape.

Don’t Miss: Nuit Blanche North (Huntsville – July)

Held each summer, Nuit Blanche North transforms downtown Huntsville into a vibrant nighttime art festival. Featuring installations, performances, and interactive exhibits, it’s one of the most unique and creative things to do in Muskoka in July.

Whether you're buying, selling, or simply exploring—these local spots remind us why Muskoka is such a special place to call home. Looking for more Muskoka hidden gems or thinking of settling down here?

Let’s connect—we’d love to help you find the perfect place to call your own in cottage country.